The Gin Mill Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to The Gin Mill, a vibrant sports and cocktail bar located in the heart of New York's Upper West Side. This local gem offers a casual and inviting atmosphere perfect for catching a game or enjoying a night out with friends. The menu is a celebration of classic American bar fare, featuring crowd-pleasers like Jalapeno Poppers, creamy Homemade Mac N' Cheese, and Old Fashioned Sliders. Don’t miss the Gin Mill Nachos Grande, loaded with savory toppings that ensure a fiesta with every bite.
For those craving a delightful twist, try their Flatbread Pizza or indulge in Sweet Potato Tater Tots. Renowned for its swift service and refreshing cocktails, The Gin Mill is not just about food; it's about creating memorable experiences. Whether you're here for the unbeatable happy hour or to relish hearty dishes, The Gin Mill promises a satisfying outing that keeps patrons coming back.
Appetizers
Appetizer Sampler Platter
4 of Wings, Mozz. Sticks, Wedges & Fingers & 1 Cheese Quesadilla (No Substitutions) Choice of 4 Sauces: Honey Mustard, Ranch, BBQ, Marinara, Bleu Cheese, Salsa, Sour Cream
Gin Mill Quesadillas
Available w. Sour Cream & Salsa
Gin Mill Nachos Grande
Topped w. Cheddar Jack, Black Beans, Jalapenos & Pico de Gallo. Available w. Sour Cream & Salsa
Chips and Salsa
Chips with Homemade Guacamole
Warm Spinach Artichoke Dip
with Tortilla Chips
Hot Dog
Hand Cut Idaho French Fries
Hand Cut Idaho Seasoned Fries
Tater Tots / Seasoned Tots
Sweet Potato Tater Tots
Homemade Crispy Onion Rings
with Homemade Sauce
Smothered Fries or Tots
Smothered with Chili, Cheese and Jalapenos Available with Sour Cream
Cheddar and Bacon Tots or Fries
with Side of Ranch
Potato Skins
Topped with Bacon & Cheddar Cheese Available with Sour Cream
Flatbread Pizza
Pizza
Main
Mozzarella Sticks(6)
Jalapeno Poppers(6)
Filled with Cream Cheese with Sour Cream
Fried Pickles
Mac N' Cheese Wedges(6)
Homemade Mac N' Cheese
A 4 Cheese Blend topped w. a Parmesan Crust
Chili Con Carne
Topped with Cheddar Jack Cheese. Served w. Tortilla Chips. Available w. Sour Cream
Old Fashioned Sliders
topped with American and Grilled Onions
Chicken Fingers
with choice of BBQ, Honey Mustard, Ranch or Bleu Cheese
Boneless Buffalo Wings
with Bleu Cheese or Ranch, Carrots & Celery
Buffalo Wings
Mild, Medium, Hot, Plain or BBQ. Available with Bleu Cheese or Ranch, Carrots and Celery
Fingers and Wings
Salads
House Salad
Caesar Salad
Dressings: Honey Mustard, Ranch, Bleu Cheese, Oil & Vinegar or Balsamic Vinaigrette
Deep Fried Oreos (5)
Desserts
Specialty Burgers
The "Healthy" Alternative (Defibrillator not included)
A Cheese Burger sandwiched between 2 Grilled Cheeses (1 with bacon, 1 with tomato).
The Gin Mill Burger
Mushrooms, Bacon, Grilled Onions, Jalapenos topped with American Cheese.
Chili Cheese Burger
with Homemade Chili & American Cheese
Pulled Pork Burger
Our Classic Burger Topped with Pulled Pork
Texas Burger
Bacon, Cheddar Cheese, BBQ Sauce & a Fried Egg.
Buffalo Burger
Mozzarella Cheese dipped in our Homemade Buffalo Sauce
Homemade Jerk Chicken Burger
A Homemade patty of Ground Chicken w. Jerk Seasoning w. BBQ Mango Chutney Sauce
NY Strip Steak Sandwich
On a Toasted Garlic Portuguese Roll with Grilled Onions & Mozzarella Cheese
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Available Buffalo Style
Southern Fried Chicken Sandwich
Available Buffalo Style
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Topped with our Homemade BBQ sauce
Grilled Chicken Wrap
Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap
Fish & Chips
Tarter Sauce on the side
Bacon, Egg and Cheese
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Sandwiches and Stuff
Slider Menu
Slider Sampler
8 Sliders, 2 each of the following: Pulled Pork, "CB", California, Mac N' Cheese
Bacon, Egg & Cheese Sliders
Pulled Pork Sliders
Veggie Patty Sliders
Chicken Parm Sliders
Topped with Mozzarella & Marinara
Buffalo Chicken Sliders
Fried Chicken Tenders covered in our House Buffalo Sauce w.side of bleu cheese or ranch
"CB" Sliders
Sliders topped with Cheddar & Bacon
California Sliders
Sliders topped with Bacon & Avocado
Meat & Potato Sliders
Sliders topped with Grilled Onions & a Potato Pancake
Mac N' Cheese Sliders
Sliders topped with American & Fried Mac N' Cheese Wedge
Cheesy Sliders
Sliders topped with American, Cheddar, Swiss & Mozzarella Cheeses
Sloppy Joe Sliders
Chicken Philly Cheese Sliders
Philly Cheese Sliders
Meatapalooza Sliders
Sliders topped with Both Pulled Pork & Bacon
1/2 Price All Beer
Drafts, Bottles Pitchers
Monday
Tuesday Ladies Night
Domestic Drafts
Frozen Margaritas
1/2 Price Shot of the Night
1/2 Price Drafts & Pitchers
Well Drinks & Shots
Wednesday
Thursday "College Night"
Bud, Bud Lt., Coors Lt. Pitchers
Sam Adams & Blue Moon Pitchers
Fireball Shots
1/2 price drinks
with Valid College ID
Drafts
Well Shots
Saturday Night "Power Hour"
Sunday Night
You Call It
Drafts, Bottles, Mixed Drinks and Shots